Survivorship Bias in Immigration Litigation
Hello everyone!
My legal practice constantly provides me with new topics for this blog. Every week, I encounter situations that reveal not only how immigration law works, but also how people think, make decisions, evaluate risks, and sometimes develop completely unrealistic expectations about their cases.
As always, I am brutally honest in my articles. I do not write to sell false hope, promise miracles, or tell readers what they want to hear. I write about what I actually observe in my practice, including uncomfortable realities that many people would rather ignore.
Today, I want to discuss a psychological phenomenon that I encounter regularly in immigration litigation: survivorship bias.
It explains why people believe that obtaining asylum is easy because someone they know won asylum. Why they believe that an EB-2 National Interest Waiver (NIW) petition can be easily approved without an attorney because someone posted a successful experience on YouTube. And why families of detained immigrants sometimes spend thousands of dollars pursuing habeas corpus litigation after reading about someone who was released from ICE custody.
The common denominator is simple: people see the winners, but they rarely see the losers.
And this distorted perception can become extremely expensive.
What Is Survivorship Bias?
Survivorship bias is a cognitive error that occurs when people focus on successful outcomes while overlooking unsuccessful cases that are less visible.
One of the most famous examples comes from World War II.
The United States military examined bombers returning from combat missions. Analysts studied the bullet holes in surviving aircraft and initially considered reinforcing the areas that had sustained the most damage.
Mathematician Abraham Wald recognized a fundamental flaw in this reasoning.
The military was examining only aircraft that had survived their missions. Aircraft that had been shot down were missing from the analysis.
Wald argued that the areas requiring additional armor were those where returning aircraft had relatively few bullet holes. Damage to those areas was more likely to prevent an aircraft from returning.
The principle was simple: studying only survivors produces a distorted understanding of the risks.
This psychological error appears everywhere: business, investing, education, and, of course, immigration litigation.
The YouTube Expert Who Won an EB-2 NIW Without an Attorney
Imagine someone who decides to prepare and file an EB-2 National Interest Waiver petition without hiring an immigration attorney.
The person researches immigration law, watches videos, prepares a petition, submits supporting documents, and eventually receives an approval notice from USCIS.
Naturally, the person is excited.
They record a YouTube video:
“How I Got My EB-2 NIW Approved Without a Lawyer!”
The video attracts 50,000 views.
Thousands of people watch it. Hundreds leave comments. Some viewers ask for petition templates, recommendation letters, and advice about preparing their own applications.
The successful applicant becomes something of an immigration expert overnight.
Other people begin to conclude that immigration lawyers are unnecessary, that the EB-2 NIW process is relatively simple, and that anyone can obtain approval by following the steps described in the video.
But there is a serious problem with this reasoning.
We are watching one person who succeeded. We are not watching everyone else who tried the same approach and failed.
Imagine, purely for illustration, that 1,000 people independently file EB-2 NIW petitions without attorneys.
Suppose 10 are approved and 990 are denied.
These figures are hypothetical, not actual USCIS statistics.
The ten successful applicants may celebrate their achievements publicly. Some may record videos, write articles, or offer consultations.
But what about the other 990?
How many of them will record a YouTube video titled:
“I Prepared My EB-2 NIW Petition Without a Lawyer, and USCIS Denied It”?
Probably very few.
People generally enjoy talking about their successes. They are considerably less enthusiastic about advertising their failures.
Someone who loses an immigration case may feel embarrassed, disappointed, or angry. They may want to forget the experience rather than discuss it publicly.
Consequently, unsuccessful applicants are largely invisible.
Meanwhile, the successful applicant’s video continues attracting views, giving thousands of people the impression that the approach works.
A video with 50,000 views is not evidence of a 50,000-person success rate. It is simply evidence that one person’s story attracted an audience.
There is another problem.
The successful applicant may have exceptional qualifications, an unusually strong professional background, or particularly compelling evidence.
The person watching the video may have none of those advantages.
Moreover, receiving an approval does not necessarily mean the applicant understands precisely why USCIS approved the petition.
For EB-2 NIW petitions, USCIS applies specific legal requirements, including the framework established in Matter of Dhanasar, 26 I&N Dec. 884 (AAO 2016).
An applicant may receive an approval despite including irrelevant documents, unnecessary arguments, or poorly structured legal analysis.
That does not make the entire petition a model worth copying.
To be clear, individuals are legally permitted to prepare many immigration petitions without attorneys, and some do so successfully.
My point is different.
The fact that someone won without an attorney tells you almost nothing about how likely you are to win without one.
To evaluate that question, you would need reliable information about both successful and unsuccessful petitions, including differences in qualifications and case characteristics.
A YouTube success story does not provide that information.
Habeas Corpus: The Illusion of Immediate Release
The consequences of survivorship bias become considerably more serious when dealing with people detained by Immigration and Customs Enforcement.
In my immigration litigation practice, I have handled cases involving prolonged detention, bond requests, habeas corpus petitions, and federal court proceedings.
One recurring problem is that families often develop unrealistic expectations after reading online stories about people released from ICE custody.
Someone posts on Facebook:
“My attorney filed habeas corpus, and the federal judge ordered my immediate release!”
The post receives hundreds of comments.
People congratulate the former detainee. Other families contact the attorney. Some begin believing that filing a federal habeas petition is a reliable way to secure immediate release.
But what are the actual probabilities?
Consider an illustrative scenario in which only 1.5% of habeas petitions result in immediate release.
I am using this percentage to demonstrate the problem, not presenting it as a verified national or California-wide statistic. The actual likelihood depends on the court, legal issues, detention authority, and other circumstances.
Imagine 1,000 immigration habeas petitions.
| Outcome | Cases |
|---|---|
| Immediate release | 15 |
| Other outcomes | 985 |
| Total | 1,000 |
Under this hypothetical scenario, only 15 people obtain immediate release.
The other 985 cases might involve denials, dismissals, pending proceedings, orders for bond hearings, or other outcomes. Some may produce meaningful legal relief without immediate release.
Nevertheless, the important point is that only 15 people achieve the specific outcome being celebrated online.
Now imagine those 15 individuals posting photographs and videos after leaving detention.
They describe their experiences, praise their lawyers, and encourage other detained immigrants not to give up.
Their stories spread through immigration groups and social media.
But where are the other 985 people?
You rarely see posts saying:
“We spent $10,000 on a habeas corpus petition, and the federal court denied relief.”
Or:
“The federal judge ordered a bond hearing, but the immigration judge denied bond, and my husband remains detained.”
Or:
“We spent months litigating, and the petition was ultimately dismissed.”
These stories exist, but they receive nowhere near the same attention.
As a result, people begin treating exceptional outcomes as though they were ordinary.
The visibility of successful habeas cases has nothing to do with their statistical frequency.
And that misunderstanding can cost families thousands of dollars.
Winning Habeas Corpus Does Not Necessarily Mean Being Released
There is another important distinction that many people overlook.
A successful habeas corpus petition does not necessarily result in immediate release from custody.
Depending on the legal circumstances, a federal court might order the government to provide a bond hearing or another constitutionally adequate procedure.
That can be a significant legal victory.
But the immigration judge may subsequently deny bond.
The detainee may therefore remain in custody despite obtaining favorable relief in federal court.
This distinction is frequently lost when people describe their cases online.
Someone hears that a federal judge granted habeas relief and assumes the detainee was released.
That assumption may be incorrect.
In immigration detention litigation, we must distinguish between a favorable judicial ruling, an order requiring further proceedings, and actual release from custody.
They are not interchangeable outcomes.
Why Someone Else’s Successful Case May Be Completely Different From Yours
Clients sometimes tell me:
“Attorney, I know someone who had exactly the same situation, and the federal judge released him.”
But when I begin examining the facts, the situations are rarely identical.
The other person may have been detained under a different statutory provision.
Their immigration proceedings may have been at a different stage.
They may have had a different detention history, criminal record, or procedural posture.
Their case may have involved different federal precedent or a different legal theory.
For example, detention under INA § 235, § 236, and § 241 can involve substantially different legal frameworks.
A person detained before entry of a final removal order may face different legal questions from someone detained after a final order.
Federal courts also operate within different circuits, and controlling precedent can differ.
Even within the same jurisdiction, differences in facts can produce different outcomes.
The fact that two people are detained by ICE does not mean they have the same legal case.
This is precisely why copying someone else’s litigation strategy can be dangerous.
Survivorship Bias in Asylum Cases
The same phenomenon affects asylum applicants.
Imagine someone receives asylum after attending an individual hearing before an immigration judge.
The person shares the good news with friends and posts about the victory on social media.
Others begin comparing their experiences.
One person says:
“He was arrested only once in Russia, and the judge granted asylum. I was arrested three times. My case must be stronger.”
But that conclusion is legally unsound.
Asylum eligibility is not determined by simply counting arrests or incidents.
The applicant must satisfy the relevant legal standards involving persecution or a well-founded fear of persecution, a protected ground, nexus, and other requirements.
Credibility, corroborating evidence, country conditions, statutory bars, and the specific circumstances of the case may all affect the outcome.
One person may win asylum after a single serious incident. Another may lose despite describing multiple arrests.
And someone reading a success story online usually does not know all the evidence presented in the successful case.
They see the outcome, not the complete record.
They see the survivor, not the process that produced the result.
The Attorney Who Advertises Only Victories
Survivorship bias also affects how prospective clients evaluate immigration attorneys.
Visit almost any immigration law firm’s social media page, and you will likely see announcements about successful cases.
“Asylum Granted!”
“Habeas Corpus Victory!”
“Green Card Approved!”
“Federal Appeal Won!”
There is nothing inherently wrong with attorneys discussing successful representations, provided their advertising complies with applicable professional rules.
But consider what is missing.
How many attorneys publish detailed accounts of their unsuccessful cases?
How many announce:
“Today, the immigration judge denied my client’s asylum application”?
Or:
“The Board of Immigration Appeals dismissed our appeal”?
Naturally, attorneys generally prefer discussing favorable results.
But this creates a selection problem.
A lawyer who publishes 20 successful cases may have handled 25 cases or 500 cases.
Without knowing the denominator, you cannot calculate a meaningful success rate.
Furthermore, the attorney handling the most difficult cases may have a lower overall success rate than an attorney who accepts only straightforward matters.
This does not necessarily mean the second attorney is more capable.
It may simply mean they handle different types of cases.
A collection of successful case announcements is marketing, not statistical evidence.
Clients should understand that distinction.
Survivorship Bias and the Sunk Cost Fallacy
Survivorship bias becomes particularly destructive when combined with another cognitive error: the sunk cost fallacy.
The sunk cost fallacy occurs when people continue investing resources in a course of action because they have already spent substantial money, time, or effort on it.
Imagine a detained immigrant whose family has already paid substantial legal fees.
The immigration judge denied bond.
A federal habeas petition was unsuccessful.
The family then consults another attorney about filing additional motions or pursuing another legal theory.
Despite the previous setbacks, they remain convinced that release is just one more filing away.
Why?
Because they have read about someone who was released after several unsuccessful attempts.
They begin thinking:
“We have already spent so much money. We cannot stop now.”
But past expenditures do not increase the legal merit of the next filing.
The correct question is not how much money has already been spent.
The correct question is whether there is a legitimate legal basis for the next step and a realistic prospect of obtaining meaningful relief.
Sometimes continued litigation is justified.
New evidence, changed circumstances, intervening judicial precedent, or an unresolved constitutional issue may warrant further action.
But repeating unsuccessful arguments without identifying a meaningful legal basis is not a sound litigation strategy.
Hope is not a substitute for legal analysis.
Why Social Media Makes the Problem Worse
Social media algorithms are designed to promote engaging content.
A video showing a person leaving an ICE detention facility is emotionally powerful.
A YouTube video titled “How I Got My Green Card Without a Lawyer” is appealing.
A detailed discussion about jurisdiction, standards of review, evidentiary burdens, and unsuccessful petitions is considerably less attractive.
As a result, social media creates a highly selective picture of immigration law.
The more dramatic the successful outcome, the more attention the story may receive.
The people who failed are often silent.
This creates a feedback loop.
Successful cases attract attention. Their visibility encourages others to imitate them. When some of those individuals succeed, they create additional success stories.
Meanwhile, the much larger population of unsuccessful applicants may remain almost completely invisible.
Eventually, certain immigration benefits or legal remedies begin to appear easier to obtain than they really are.
Yet visibility and probability are fundamentally different concepts.
A thousand people can watch the same successful case a hundred times.
That does not create a hundred thousand successful cases.
It remains one successful case.
Immigration Litigation Is Not a Lottery
Another misconception I regularly encounter is that filing more motions, petitions, and appeals necessarily improves a person’s chance of success.
Some clients approach litigation as though every additional filing were another lottery ticket.
If the immigration judge denies an application, they want to appeal.
If the Board of Immigration Appeals dismisses the appeal, they want to file a petition for review.
If a bond request fails, they want to file habeas corpus.
If habeas relief is denied, they want another motion.
Sometimes these steps are legally appropriate and necessary. Federal appellate review, in particular, can be essential when immigration authorities commit reviewable legal errors.
But the mere availability of a procedural mechanism does not mean there is a viable claim.
An appeal requires a basis for challenging the lower tribunal’s decision.
A habeas petition requires a legally cognizable challenge within the federal court’s jurisdiction.
A motion to reopen or reconsider must satisfy its applicable requirements.
Filing multiple documents does not automatically improve the underlying legal position.
Litigation should follow a coherent legal strategy, not an emotional desire to keep trying.
What Clients Should Understand About Probability
Legal outcomes are never determined entirely by statistics.
Even when a particular remedy has a low overall success rate, an individual case may present unusually strong legal grounds.
Conversely, a remedy with a relatively high overall success rate may be inappropriate for a particular applicant.
This is why competent legal analysis must consider both general trends and individual circumstances.
Before beginning litigation, clients should understand several important questions:
- What specific legal violation or basis for relief is being asserted?
- What remedy does the court or agency actually have authority to grant?
- What procedural or jurisdictional obstacles exist?
- What are the realistic costs, risks, and potential benefits?
- Are there alternative legal strategies?
- What makes this particular case different from the successful cases described online?
A responsible attorney should explain both the strengths and weaknesses of a case.
That does not mean promising an outcome or assigning an artificial percentage to every legal question.
It means helping the client make an informed decision.
Why I Believe Attorneys Should Discuss Unsuccessful Cases
In my own practice, I have experienced successful outcomes, difficult litigation, and unfavorable decisions.
I believe there is considerable educational value in discussing all of them.
A successful case may demonstrate how a particular legal argument persuaded a court.
An unsuccessful case may reveal a procedural trap, an unfavorable interpretation of the law, or a weakness in litigation strategy.
Both experiences are valuable.
This is one reason I write about actual situations encountered in my practice.
I do not believe that immigration attorneys should create the impression that every case can be won, every detainee can be released, or every unfavorable decision can be overturned.
That is not how litigation works.
Sometimes even carefully prepared, legally supported arguments fail.
Sometimes a court adopts the government’s position.
Sometimes a client has compelling personal circumstances but lacks a viable legal remedy.
And sometimes the most valuable advice an attorney can provide is to explain why a proposed litigation strategy is unlikely to succeed.
Clients may not enjoy hearing that advice.
But an uncomfortable assessment today can prevent substantial financial and emotional losses tomorrow.
Conclusion: The People You Never Hear About
Let us return to the examples discussed earlier.
A person obtains an EB-2 NIW approval without an attorney and publishes a YouTube video that attracts 50,000 views.
A detained immigrant obtains immediate release through habeas corpus, and the story circulates widely through immigration communities.
An asylum applicant receives a favorable decision and enthusiastically describes the experience online.
All these stories may be genuine.
But what about the unsuccessful applicants?
What about the denied petitions, dismissed appeals, and unsuccessful habeas cases?
What about the families who spent their savings on litigation that did not produce the expected results?
Their experiences are rarely part of the public conversation.
And that is precisely the problem.
Survivorship bias makes extraordinary successes appear ordinary because the unsuccessful majority is largely invisible.
When evaluating immigration options, do not ask only whether someone else succeeded.
Ask how many people attempted the same thing, how many failed, why the successful cases were different, and whether those differences apply to your circumstances.
YouTube popularity is not evidence of legal expertise.
Social media success stories are not reliable statistical samples.
And another person’s favorable court decision is not a prediction of your own outcome.
Ultimately, effective immigration litigation requires legal knowledge, evidence, realistic expectations, and a long-term strategy.
Learn from successful cases. But pay equally close attention to unsuccessful ones. Sometimes the cases nobody celebrates provide the most valuable lessons.
Ernest Goodman is a New York-licensed attorney practicing immigration law, federal appellate litigation, removal defense, and federal habeas corpus proceedings. His practice includes appeals before the Board of Immigration Appeals and petitions for review before United States Courts of Appeals.
Attorney Advertising. This article is for general informational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. The numerical examples are hypothetical and do not represent established USCIS approval rates or nationwide habeas corpus release statistics. Past results do not guarantee similar outcomes. Every case depends on its individual facts, applicable law, and procedural history.
.
